Casino Royale Comparison

Novel Synopsis:

How do they stack up? Movies vs Novels - James Bond
In the 1953 novel, 007 is given the mission to defeat Le Chiffre, a SMERSH agent working for the Russians in a high stakes Baccarat game. This is a situation where the movie has mirrored the novel to the best extent that it possibly can. When the books were written, the whole world was hip deep in the cold war which pitted east against west. All the characters are there, 007, Le Chiffre, Rene Mathis and Vesper Lynd. As the movie depicts Le Chiffre loses ca $100,000,000 of his clients money in a botched terrorist attack against Skyfleet's newest airline. In the book Le Chiffre loses 80,000,000 Francs in a botched real estate deal involving brothels in southern France. Both story lines are fairly similar, his [ Le Chiffre] greed has gotten him into a pickle with his bosses. Hence the high stakes card games to try to win their money back. Baccarat figures into the novel because that was an extremely popular card game at the time, where as Hold'em Poker is today. I assume the differences were so the audience could follow the game.

Differences:

The major differences between the film and book are as follows, Rene Mathis was not bent and Vesper fed Bond's identity to the Russians. Some nice touches that the movie lent that the book did not, was closure on a few fronts. First at the end of the movie Bond takes out Mr. White, Vesper's contact and person most likely blackmailing her. Both book and movie show Vesper leaving clues after her death so that Bond could follow up and exact revenge. In the book Vesper was be threatened by SMERSH to do these acts because they had kidnapped and threatened to kill her lover who was agent for MI6.

The reason the movie had changed the antagonists to terrorists is the mere fact that cold war is over, and free-lance bad guys are always far more entertaining. My judgement on the subject book and movie are great thrills, despite being made over 50 years apart.

Chapter Topics:

  1. The Secret Agent:
    • Observation of LeChiffre at the casino
    • Bond's cover story
  2. Dossier for M:
    • background on LeChiffre
      • LeChiffre is one of SMERSH's paymasters (or accountants) for a Communist-controlled transportation trade union in Alsace, France. This union is an important "fifth-column" (a secret, insurgent group that could be activated in times of war) for Russia.
      • LeChiffre is on the brink of financial disaster. His chain of brothels went under when France passed a law making prostitution a criminal offense. These brothels were funded with union money, i.e. SMERSH's money.
      • SMERSH is unhappy with LeChiffre and are aware of his financial failures.
      • LeChiffre is adept with small arms and knives. He carries three razorblades at all times: in his hat, his shoe, and his cigarette case.
      • Department I: in charge of counter-intelligence among Soviet organizations at home and abroad
      • Department II: Operations, including executions
      • Department III: Administration and Finance
      • Department IV: investigations and legal work. Personnel.
      • Department V: Prosecutions, passing final judgments on all suspects.
  3. Number 007:
    • Bond meets with M and receives a briefing
    • Our first glimpse of Bond's relationship with M
  4. L'Ennemi Ecoute:
    • Mathis and the radio
    • Introduction of the Muntzes
  5. The Girl From Headquarters:
    • History of the Casino Royale
    • Initial description of Vesper Lynd
  6. Two Men in Straw Hats:
    • "Red Man" and "Blue Man" detonate a suicide-bomb in an attempt to kill Bond.
  7. Rouge et Noir:
    • Bond describes his relationship to and philosophy about gambling
    • Introduction to and background on Felix Leiter
    • Recipe for "The Vesper Martini"





joshiorio
joshiorio
Latest page update: made by joshiorio , Saturday, 2:41 PM EST (about this update About This Update joshiorio added more to chapter topics - joshiorio

61 words added
2 words deleted
1 image added
1 image deleted

view changes

- complete history)
More Info: links to this page
Started By Thread Subject Replies Last Post
joshiorio Book Club: Ch 1-7 (page: 1 2) 34 Today, 5:22 PM EST by JustinAtheropinion
joshiorio
Thread started: Saturday, 10:06 AM EST  Watch
The first sentence of Chapter 1 sets the stage for a different Bond than we're used to in the films. Fleming begins the novel by describing how casinos disgust Bond: "The scent and smoke and sweat of a casino are nauseating at three in the morning." It could be the casino, or it could be the "seventieth cigarette" that Bond's smokes by the end of Chapter 1. We rarely see cases where the cinematic Bond is effected at all by his environment. Bond never shivers, he never has the sun in his eyes, he generally doesn't sweat, and he certainly doesn't take notice of the stench that emerges from casinos. Bond smokes occasionally in the early films... but 70 cigarettes a day... he's clearly not in control of his smoking habit.

In Chapter 6, we see a few more examples of Bond-as-human as opposed to Bond-as-superhero. During the hatted bomber scene, once the bombs go off prematurely, Bond gets back to his feet and vomits. After Mathis has collected him and he's back in his hotel room, Bond stares out the window "enjoying being alive". In these two scenes, we see Bond react physically to being in a stressful situation, and then we see him reflect back on his near-death experience.

In short, Bond struggles, both physically and emotionally with the sresses of his job. We see this kind of reflection during the film on Bond's yacht as he contemplates leaving MI6. The difference though is that he's thinking about leaving because of his love for Vesper, not because of the demands of the job. While Bond doesn't consider leaving MI6 here, we begin to understand that his character doubts, has weaknesses, and is a bit more complex that the cinematic portrayals.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None (edit keyword tags)
Show Last Reply
QuartermasterQ movie and book 10 Dec 19 2008, 8:25 PM EST by S3N70R
QuartermasterQ
Thread started: Dec 7 2008, 1:36 PM EST  Watch
The 2 things i liked in the book better were that they played bacarrat instead of Texas hold em. I guess they did that because it was such a main part that they had to play a game the audience would understand, whereas in all the other films the casino scenes were minor. I also didnt like how in the movie Mathis was a supposed traitor. that was dumb.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None (edit keyword tags)
Show Last Reply
alexberg Great idea kuh178! 0 Jul 7 2007, 1:54 AM EDT by alexberg
alexberg
Thread started: Jul 7 2007, 1:54 AM EDT  Watch
Thanks for getting this page rolling. I'm looking forward to seeing more movie and novel comparisons added!
1  out of 2 found this valuable. Do you?    
Keyword tags: None (edit keyword tags)

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)